A recent statewide poll shows that most North Carolina voters want judges to make decisions based on the Constitution and the law, rather than partisan politics. The survey found that 87% of respondents support judicial independence, even if court rulings differ from their own political views or those of their party. This sentiment is shared across party lines: 89% of Democrats, 80% of Republicans, and 90% of unaffiliated voters expressed this preference.
The poll was conducted by Opinion Diagnostics and commissioned by Common Cause North Carolina, a nonpartisan grassroots organization focused on democracy and accountable governance. The group promotes equal rights, encourages public participation in politics, and advances initiatives such as fair redistricting and government transparency according to its official website.
Sailor Jones, State Director of Common Cause North Carolina, said: “It’s clear that North Carolina voters want fair and independent courts that put their constitutionally protected freedoms above partisan politics. North Carolinians’ understanding of the major role judges play in their daily lives will likely mean these races will be top of mind for millions of voters when they cast their ballots this year, including in a pivotal seat on the state Supreme Court.”
The survey also revealed that 72% of respondents think at least sometimes about how the NC Supreme Court affects their lives; one-quarter often consider its impact. Opinions about the court are mixed. Currently, more voters view the NC Supreme Court negatively (38%) than positively (32%), while 29% remain unsure.
Since gaining a majority after the 2022 election, Republican justices led by Chief Justice Paul Newby have issued several high-profile rulings. One decision in 2023 held that North Carolinians cannot challenge voting districts in court over claims of partisan gerrymandering.
Most voters disagree with this ruling: 76% believe partisan gerrymandering should be illegal—an opinion held by majorities across political affiliations (79% Democrats, 66% Republicans, and 82% unaffiliated). Additionally, there is broad support for courts protecting against racial discrimination in drawing voting maps; 82% favor such safeguards (93% Democrats, 66% Republicans, and 85% unaffiliated).
Common Cause North Carolina has been active for over five decades promoting open government and equal representation throughout all counties in the state according to its official website. Its advocacy has influenced issues like redistricting reform through both policy work and court involvement.
The poll surveyed 671 registered North Carolina voters between September 15-17, 2025. It has a margin of error of plus or minus 3.8%.
See the poll results, crosstabs, and polling memo here.
###
